J.P. Morgan has adjusted its outlook on South African equities, downgrading them from “overweight” to “neutral,” a move that reflects growing apprehension regarding the nation’s economic trajectory and the perceived efficacy of ongoing policy reforms. The brokerage’s decision, revealed in a recent advisory note, underscores the persistent challenges facing Africa’s most industrialized economy.
“While South Africa’s investment case on reforms remains an attractive point of departure, it is unlikely to result in meaningful (economic) growth that’s above 2% in the coming two years,” J.P. Morgan stated. This assessment highlights a critical concern: despite government efforts, sustained and robust economic expansion remains elusive.
For many South African citizens, the implications of this economic stagnation are deeply felt. The nation has grappled with high levels of inequality and unemployment since the 2008-09 global financial crisis, and the inability to achieve substantial growth exacerbates these issues. As South African Reserve Bank (SARB) Governor Lesetja Kganyago indicated in a January interview with Reuters, “economic growth could be close to 2% in 2025,” a figure that underscores the tempered expectations.
President Cyril Ramaphosa’s recent pledge to launch a “second wave of reforms,” focusing on bolstering state-owned enterprises and infrastructure investment, offers a glimmer of hope. However, the brokerage’s analysis suggests that these efforts may not yield immediate or substantial results. “We expect foreign investors to apply a wait-and-see approach while domestic investors will have to straddle the options of GNU’s imperfect execution of its reform agenda,” J.P. Morgan explained. This cautious stance reflects a broader sentiment of uncertainty among investors.
Read Also: South Africa’s Economic Outlook Brightens, But Inflation Clouds Loom
Adding to the complexity of the situation are geopolitical factors. The strained relationship between South Africa and the United States, stemming from disagreements over land policy and South Africa’s case against Israel at the International Court of Justice, introduces further volatility. As J.P. Morgan noted, “Global dynamics resulting in South Africa/U.S. relations being strained by matters involving expropriation, ICJ case and domestic affairs around affirmative action…create uncertainty around the performance of South Africa’s domestic assets.” This external pressure further complicates the domestic economic landscape.
From my perspective, the human impact is significant. The average South African, already burdened by economic hardship, faces heightened uncertainty as investor confidence wavers. The hope that reforms would translate into tangible improvements in their daily lives is tempered by the reality of slow growth and external pressures.
In terms of regional investment preferences, J.P. Morgan now favors Emerging European equities within the Central & Eastern Europe, Middle East & Africa (CEEMEA) region, while still maintaining a preference for South African stocks over those in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region. This highlights a nuanced approach to emerging market investments, where regional dynamics play a crucial role.
The situation calls for a balanced perspective. While the challenges are undeniable, it is also essential to recognize the ongoing efforts to address them. The success of these efforts, however, remains to be seen.
